Don’t Look At Me Like That: The Staring Styles of the Lebanese

IMG_1446

In this case, I was asking for it.

To my fellow Lebanese,

Please stop staring at me with that unbecoming slack-jawed bewilderment. For a culture that stresses on social etiquette, we are disappointingly inept at recognizing our own individual faux pas which culminate to form one severe epidemic otherwise referred to as “rudeness”. Of course, many of you who engage in unnecessary staring contests with the unsuspecting do not believe it is rude to stare at someone with my appearance. Since my very existence is “inappropriate” in your eyes, you may feel that you are excused from conducting yourself in a manner that is even remotely respectable. You are not. You only think that you are, and that is entirely your responsibility. So, kindly stop giving me that look that so clearly communicates your belief that I am bringing your unmannerly behavior upon myself by choosing to express my identity.

How self-centered you must be to come to the erroneous conclusion that I make it my express goal to confuse you with my short hair, chosen apparel, and gender nonconformity. Oh, I’m sorry, do I presume too much? Well, so do you when you stare daggers at me as though I am infecting the very atmosphere around us. You see, I was (un)fortunate enough to gain insight on the nature of your thoughts from many a “People Watching” session with my lovely family members who often make it a point to blithely draw one another’s attention to a myriad of “abnormal” personalities in public and over coffee, no less.
My family is especially talented at detecting and outing trans* individuals who are not, for whatever reason, “passable”. The following are actual quotes by members of my immediate family which I will unapologetically share:

You see that short fat man over there? It‘s not actually a man. If you pay close attention to the chest and face, you can tell its a woman pretending to be a man. Disgusting, ma hek?”

“Ya lateef! Look at that woman parking her car! LOOK! Is it a woman? It looks like a man. I’ve never seen a woman with a jaw like that. What do you want to bet its a man dressed in women’s clothing, eh? How do you think he hides his penis in a dress that short?”

Since my family is blissfully in denial about my identification as a transman, I am forced to sit through this degrading social exercise — if you can even call uncivil verbal bashings an “exercise” — in abhorrent silence. Naturally, should my family glance others staring at me with the same discourteous looks they, themselves, frequently give to others who share a similar apparent disregard for gender conformity, they attribute this scrutiny to my intimidating height, my noteworthy breadth, or, as my mother likes to remind me all too often, my being “a very pretty girl”. This brings me to my next point: I have been challenged before by friends claiming that, since there is no possible way to know what a person is thinking, I cannot immediately assume I am being stared at because I am a transman unabashedly treading the streets of Beirut.  Perhaps they are admiring my outfit or think that I am attractive, or maybe they recognize me from somewhere but are simply too shy to step forward.

I want to say “good point”,  but the diplomat in me cannot prevail on this subject. When you have been stared at for as long as I have, you learn to distinguish between stares that convey piqued interest and those that convey pure discomfort and/or revulsion. You do not have to be a facial expression expert to note the not-so subtle difference between the two, so even though I admittedly lack telepathic abilities, I think I am capable of discerning the expressions I continue to receive on a daily basis, from the innocuous greeting of the stranger who raises her eyebrows in acknowledgement to the contemptuous curl of one’s lips paired with the open threat of sustained eye-contact. Sadly, the latter is more prevalent in my daily life and anyone who has walked alongside me during any day of the week can attest to this.

To those of you reading this post who now realize that you may have subjected others to this inadmissible habit of prolonged staring, here is your chance to reassess your own behavior instead of unjustly forcing others into a corner with the power of your gaze alone. You must understand the implications of your unrevised actions. By staring at others for extended periods of time, you are essentially informing that person without words, and in no uncertain terms, that there is something fundamentally wrong with them, whether or not that was your intention.
We Lebanese have a repugnant reputation for shamelessly staring at others, and whether you’re a woman accused of encouraging men to leer at you due to your “provocative” taste in fashion or a woman allegedly inviting crude remarks from men because you’re female, a person who is overweight or obese and made to feel ashamed for your body type, a woman with short hair or a man with long hair, someone with a disability or a stigmatized disorder, or any one just trying to express your identity in a way that suits you, you will understand the kind of internal turmoil that arises from the callous disregard of others for your feelings as a human being presumptuously labeled “abnormal” and, therefore, deserving of others’ inappropriate breach of basic social etiquette.

Sincerely urging you to be more self-aware,
Lore

P.S. You would do well to remember that my chosen gender expression has no impact on your life, whatsoever. Having said that, you can go ahead and stop trying to decipher my physiological sex by undressing me with your eyes. It’s fucking rude.

“A Thing of the West”: On Passing Through Lebanon

From my personal sketchbook.

From my personal sketchbook.

It usually goes without saying — I will say it anyway — that each individual undergoes different experiences and faces them in her/his/zheir own unique way. Just as some highly respectful people refuse to speak on behalf of others when no one asked to be represented by that speaker, so shall I maintain that the pleasures I have reaped and the trials that have encountered me as a transman residing in Beirut are my own.

That being said, I feel I must address an issue that has repeatedly made itself known throughout many an interpersonal interaction between myself and others, mostly cisgendered individuals who sincerely sympathize for my “situation”, but cannot ever truly empathize with me.
Upon making my gender identity known, I am often met with appreciated albeit all-too-formulaic expressions of the aforementioned sympathy delivered in the form of advice. Now, see, this is common social practice, especially between good friends: one voices a concern or confesses some personal strife, and a good friend is typically inclined to receive this information with a sympathetic ear and/or useful advice at the ready. As reassuring as it is to know that people try hard to care about the quality of my life, I cannot help but speculate the range of responses I receive when I posit my transgenderism not as a problem that requires solving, but a mere fact I feel comfortable sharing since I presently have no intentions of ever “passing” for a cis-male. Such responses include the pressing inquiry as to my long-term plan about leaving Lebanon, and therein lies the real problem.

I must admit that, in the past, when asked if I intended to leave Beirut behind to set up my new life elsewhere, my reflexive response was some cousin of a definite “Of course!” or a sardonic yet secretly wistful “Inno, what do you think?” I have no explanation for the firm conviction that my being trans would necessitate migration to the western world, where people are supposedly far more accepting of my self-proclaimed male identity, other than that this suggestion was the most frequently uttered piece of advice I had ever been given, and was always so unequivocally stated that the mere prospect of offering up a counterargument seemed so ridiculous. In hindsight, I knew nothing of the West other than what I had aggregated over the course of a childhood spent in front of the television absorbing its culture with wide-eyed fascination, observing its spectacular “otherness” that repelled my elders, yet inspired within me infantile dreams of enjoying its so-called freedoms.

Socio-political strife, pointless sectarianism, insufficient salaries and wages, constant threat of war, corrupt and power-hungry representatives whose grips on their positions are vise-like, lack of promising educational opportunities for Lebanese graduates, lack of proper law enforcement, lack of legal regard or concern for the rights of women, the overall apprehensive mistreatment of the LGBTQIA community…name your reason for wanting to leave if you haven’t left already. Still, it strikes me as odd (understatement of the century) that the only reasonable solution to my “problem” would be to uproot my entire life for the possibility of having a better one in some strange far-off place across a vast ocean, away from family and friends who consistently cautioned me never to grow too attached to the overcrowded waiting room that is Lebanon before a good portion of them flew the coop themselves. It would appear this, too, has become common practice.

A great many of us are led to believe that we simply don’t belong here for one reason or another. We are born or brought here, we grow up and endure the chaotic goings-on we later come to quietly appreciate, but we continue to exhibit the overt distaste characteristic of the Lebanese people lest any one of us express an actual iota of affection toward our home because, after all, we do not belong here. I, a transman, do not belong here, for transgenderism, according to my many sympathizers, is a thing of the West. Believing this myself, I sailed for years through the veins of Beirut as another speck eagerly anticipating the day I would permeate Lebanon’s borders to join the 20-odd million other Lebanese living abroad. This thought, once a delightful flight of fancy, now fills me with a distinct distaste rooted in deep sadness which I am forced to swallow each time I am presumptuously told that I would be better off somewhere in the United States, Europe, or Australia. Fuck it, who knows? Maybe I would be better off. That is not what bothers me. What bothers me is the immediacy at which I am expected, by others and myself, to succumb to the ostensible fact that the uncompromising status quo is here to stay, while I…am not.

I am going to ask a difficult question that is directed more to myself than to you, the reader, but by asking it here, I can only hope that I am on the right track to finally finding an answer:
If I leave Lebanon to seek out my life elsewhere, if I abandon the ideals I was told never to possess in the first place, if I shove a geographical space between myself and the family who would scarcely accept me, if I take everything I have learned and all the life-lessons I have amassed from my life here to a foreign place, and if I tell myself that Lebanon wasn’t/isn’t/never will be the home I deserve, will I be contributing to my country’s continued existence as the waiting room from which many of us reluctantly transition because we are convinced it will never become the home we truly deserve?

Sincerely wondering,
Lore

P.S. It should not have been so difficult to type the words “my country”, and yet, it was.